I have confused myself. It was never like this with Euro 2008 - I almost crashed my car racing home from work to catch games and lived on delivery food to ensure my time away from the couch was kept to a minimum. So what is it about women's football that leaves me cold and unenthusiastic.
As with any good tactical analysis, let's start at the back:
- Goalkeepers - I am yet to see an outstanding save from a female goalkeeper. I do not for a second doubt that many have been made, but that's not my point (otherwise I fall straight into ignoramus territory). My point is that I have not seen any. In any women's match I've watched there is a distinct lack of quality goalkeeping - poor handling, dodgy positioning, a reluctance to impose themselves within their box. When the last line of defence offers little confidence, it makes for a lottery rather than a game of football.
- Quality - There is clearly world-class talent on show outfield in women's football, but rarely do two evenly matched teams take the field against one another. The standard between the good and the not so good players, even within one team, can be appalling. Watching a top class man's game offers signifcant quality across the park - watching a top class women's game highlights the talented few exposing the many.
- Coverage - More important than either of the above is that I don't see or hear enough of women's football to care about it. On Football Focus at the weekend I'm confident that they will start with a review of the day's upcoming Premiership games, followed by a summary of the home nations' performances in the World Cup qualifiers, before eventually tagging on a story about how well the English team did to get to the final (I say this because I've just checked and the final score was 6-2 to Germany - dodgy goalkeeping, I expect!).
Hey- very interesting post. I like how you kept it very objective.
ReplyDeleteI'm a female footballer (started playing when I was 4) and although I have utmost respect for the technical ability of top class female footballers, it's the pace of the game that makes me not really watch.
And that's probably not going to change.
That said, I think the sport is wonderful for participation. So many benefits.
Thanks for reading, Katie. I'd love to see women's football given a real chance, but worry that the men's game is too dominant nowadays. I don't think the women's game will ever reach parity in my lifetime, but that's no reason not to support it as it clearly gives many young women fantastic opportunities their mothers never had.
ReplyDelete